10 Yrs#
knalb
#1
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
It has been 8 and 4 months since the first Game of the month has taken place and throughout this time we have played through 133 games. Throughout this month I will be ranking the games by there:
-Length
-Thread Discussions
-Franchise counts
-Backlogged
-Completion
-Completion over backlogged
-Retirement
-Retirement as a percentage
-Global ranking
-Personnal ranking

I ask people to use this thread to discuss there Favourite moments and games from the GotM. Games you wouldn't of picked up if not for GotM and perhaps your own personal ranking of the GotM games
10 Yrs#
knalb
#2
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
Length

So we all here to find out the length of a game so of course the first ranking will be how long it will take to beat a game. To do this I used the Average game length for all playstyles. If you were to place all of the games in the GotM thread though it would take you 112 days 5 hours and 3 minutes of non stop play. Luckily the average length of the Game of the month games is 20 hours 24 minutes. Now without further due the ranking for all of the games:

Longest Games
User Image
3rd- The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 99 Hours 1 minute

User Image
2nd - Elden Ring - 110 hours 10 minutes

User Image
1st - Persona 5 Royal - 126 hours 11 minutes

Shortest games
User Image
3rd - Bit. Trip Flux - 2 hours 6 minutes

User Image
2nd - Bit. Trip Void - 2 hours 4 minutes

User Image
1st - Minesweeper - 1 Hour 33 minutes

Full List
1 Persona 5 Royal 126:11
2 Elden Ring 110:10
3 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 99:01
4 Fallout 4 87:32
5 Lost Odyssey 70:20
6 Yakuza 0 61:58
7 Dragon Age Origins 59:01
8 Borderlands 2 58:50
9 Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch 58:47
10 Final Fantasy VII 52:40
11 Odin Sphere 48:20
12 Horizon Zero Dawn 47:49
13 The Witcher 47:43
14 Hades 47:07
15 Hollow Knight 43:11
16 Okami 40:58
17 Valkyria Chronicles 38:48
18 Borderlands 35:21
19 The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker 35:06
20 Spiritfarer 34:26
21 Nier 34:08
22 Disco Elysium 32:34
23 Yakuza Kiwami 31:36
24 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time 31:00
25 Earthbound 30:48
26 Wargroove 29:33
27 Deus Ex 28:57
28 The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask 28:46
29 Borderlands: The Pre sequel 28:41
30 Prey (2017) 28:15
31 Chrono Trigger 27:43
32 The Outer Worlds 27:32
33 Live a Live 25:52
34 OMORI 24:59
35 Deadly Premonition 24:36
36 Hitman (2016) 23:34
37 Fallout 22:43
38 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order 22:39
39 Super Mario Galaxy 21:32
40 Alien: Isolation 21:30
41 LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game 21:17
42 Crypt of the NecroDancer 20:57
43 Darksiders 20:13
44 Final Fantasy 20:12
45 Resident Evil 4 19:56
46 Blasphemous 19:19
47 The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages 19:14
48 The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap 18:59
49 The Evil Within 18:36
50 Rayman Legends 17:38
51 999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors 17:19
52 Tunic 16:36
53 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past 16:25
54 Omikron: The Nomad Soul 16:25
55 Doom (2016) 15:36
56 Metroid Prime 15:26
57 Unreal Gold 15:15
58 Bioshock 14:53
59 The Messenger 14:26
60 Pyre 14:11
61 Resident Evil 13:58
62 Bayonetta 13:58
63 Celeste 13:51
64 Alan Wake 13:50
65 Banjo Kazooie 13:48
66 Bioshock 2 13:45
67 Prince of Persia 2008 13:35
68 Child of Light 13:26
69 Oddworld: Abe’s Oddysee 13:26
70 Corpse Party 13:00
71 Thimbleweed Park 12:46
72 Parasite Eve 12:25
73 A Plague Tale: Innocence 12:22
74 Dead Space 12:21
75 Bit. Trip Runner 12:18
76 Beyond Good & Evil 11:58
77 Conker’s Bad Fury Day 11:47
78 Bit. Trip Presents Runner 2: Future Legend of Rhythm Alien 11:39
79 Night in the Woods 11:33
80 Doom 3 11:30
81 Bayonetta 2 11:18
82 Tales from the Borderlands 11:13
83 Hyper Light Drifter 11:11
84 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night 10:30
85 Kentucky Route Zero 10:29
86 Shadow of the Colossus 10:28
87 Soma 10:20
88 Ori and the Blind Forest 10:05
89 Binary Domain 10:04
90 God of War 09:46
91 The Cat Lady 09:43
92 Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak 09:20
93 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance 09:20
94 Stories: The Path of Destinies 09:08
95 Cthulhu Saves the World 09:00
96 DOOM II: Hell On Earth 08:39
97 Super Metroid 08:24
98 Transistor 08:18
99 Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice 08:15
100 Observer 08:04
101 Project Zero / Fatal frame 08:03
102 Silent Hill 07:46
103 MediEvil 07:22
104 Super Mario World 07:04
105 The Secret of Monkey Island 07:01
106 Outlast 06:21
107 Beneath a Steel Sky 06:19
108 Doom (1993) 05:58
109 Oxenfree 05:42
110 Saya No Uta 05:35
111 Doki Doki Literature Club 05:28
112 Bit. Trip Beat 04:38
113 Donkey Kong Country 04:36
114 Little Nightmares 04:19
115 Gris 04:10
116 Untitled Goose Game 03:47
117 Mega Man 3 03:41
118 Bit. Trip Core 03:40
119 Clock Tower 03:30
120 Castlevania 03:21
121 Mega Man 4 03:19
122 Mega Man 5 03:15
123 Mega Man 2 02:58
124 Mega Man 02:54
125 Mega Man 6 02:51
126 Maldita Castilla 02:38
127 Journey 02:25
128 A Short Hike 02:21
129 Bit. Trip Fate 02:17
130 Bit. Trip Flux 02:06
131 Bit. Trip Void 02:04
132 Minesweeper 01:33
5 Yrs#
Knowbowl
#3
's Avatar
5 Yrs#
I'll take the ones I've played through and rank them from least favorite to favorite.

#30 - Little Nighmares
I just wanted more from this game. It ended up being some fairly simple puzzles with light horror, and I got bored.

#29 - Borderlands 2
On paper I'm totally down for a grindy FPS with tons of weapons and upgrades, but I just hated all the stylistic choices made for this game. The characters are not funny, the cell shaded graphics gave me headaches, and the grind got boring quick.

#28 - Untitled Goose Game
It was okay. Fun for an hour or so, but then it just felt like simple puzzles with no real dynamic interactions.

#27 - Hitman (2016)
I can appreciate these games (considering I've played the entire trilogy), but I just don't find them particularly engaging. My main gripe is a lack of interesting story or characters, though I know that's not what the game was going for necessarily.

#26 - Prey (2017)
Really cool world and environments, but the combat felt very underdeveloped. By the end I was ready to be done.

#25 - Doom (1993)
Great game for its time, and has aged pretty well, but I can't put it higher against games that were more engaging for me.

#24 - Outlast
Decent horror title that had me engaged from beginning to end, though most of the engagements felt too scripted.

#23 - Doom (2016)
Great combat and levels, but just not my cup of tea. I'm not huge on unnecessary gore.

#22 - Hellblade Senua's Sacrifice
Had some interesting levels and mechanics, though felt a little too simple by the end.

#21 - Banjo Kazooie
Donkey Kong 64 > Banjo Kazooie

#20 - Bioshock 2
Good game with fun skills and level design, though it felt inferior to the first.

#19 - Celeste
I'm not generally into side scrollers, but this game was very good. Would be higher on my list if it was more my type of game.

#18 - Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order
Combat was pretty good, but I loved the level design and Worlds. Dark Souls did it first though, and better.

#17 - Bioshock
A masterpiece in some ways, but lacking in others for me. The characters are all interacted with through calls and tapes and the looting is too aggressive.

#16 - Beyond Good and Evil
Hard to describe, but very fun. A surprisingly original puzzle platformer.

#15 - Zelda A Link to the Past
Great dungeons. Overworld was a bit tedious though.

#14 - Fallout 4
Open World RPGs are my favorite type of game and though this one wasn't the best Fallout, it's still a great game.

#13 - Dragon Age Origins
Great characters, writing, and quests. Combat was a little too tedious.

#12 - Lost Odyssey
Surprisingly solid JRPG. Better than many of the Final Fantasy games in my opinion. Very well worth a playthrough.

#11 - A Plague Tale Innocence
Great story, characters and gameplay. No complaints really, I just can't put it in my top 10 against the rest of the games on this list.

#10 - Shadow of the Colossus
No other game like it. Some of the most epic boss battles ever. The game needs something more outside of those bosses though.

#9 - Dead Space
A thrilling horror title that does not let up. Only complaint is enemy variety and overuse of enemies taking away from the horror by the end.

#8 - The Outer Worlds
I love the level design and writing. Not the most polished game, but feels like a classic yet original open world RPG.

#7 - Resident Evil 4
Leon <3

#6 - Zelda Breath of the Wild
The best and most unique sandbox open world RPG out there. I just wish it had more characters, dialog, and story.

#5 - Alan Wake
A thriller title with horror elements that absolutely nails the atmosphere. I can't stop coming back to it.

#4 - The Evil Within
In many ways this and the sequel are better than Resident Evil in my opinion. Each level is unique and changes up the variables so that the game always feels fresh. Great DLC too.

#3 - Alien Isolation
The levels look plucked straight out of the Alien movies. The AI is phenomenal and adds so much to the scare factor. This game is near perfect in my opinion. Where's the sequel?

#2 - Soma
I'm realizing many of these top ones are horror games. I'm generally not biased towards them, I guess that's just how this ranking worked out based on the games in the list. Soma is my favorite horror title with perfect atmosphere, unique enemies, level design, and story. It's everything a horror game should strive to be.

#1 - Elden Ring
One of the most engaging experiences I've had while playing a game. Once you get going there's no stopping. It's hard, but there always feels like something you can do to progress. It feels like 5 games worth of content stuffed into one.
13 YrsF#
Everdred
Staff
#4
's Avatar
13 YrsF#
Replying to Knowbowl
Great list with great games. Hard to disagree with anything there. Love the horror picks, those are some of my favorites.
4 Yrs#
GreenStarfish
#5
's Avatar
4 Yrs#
Turns out I haven't finished a lot of GoTM games. Didn't even reach 10, although I guess that'll change when I finish Persona 5.

Here's my quick ranking:

9. Donkey Kong Country
Difficulty is imbalanced between levels and bosses and I wouldn't have been able to beat it without save states.

8. Super Mario World
More reasonable levels of difficulty but I still used save states.

7. Untitled Goose Game
A fun short puzzle game that had an unnecessary and unfun speedrun mode that stopped me from 100% it.

6. Live A Live
Fun gameplay and a great interconnected story. The gameplay takes a bit of a hit in the last two chapters though.

5. Hollow Knight
A really fun Metroidvania with deep lore. It's just way too difficult for me and can get quite frustrating.

4. Ori and the Blind Forest
Another solid Metroidvania but this one isn't frustrating and the mechanics are really fun to cheese around with.

3. Celeste
The very emotional and impactful story compliments the difficult but doable gameplay well.

2. Hitman 2016
It has a mysterious and interesting story combined (mostly) with fun levels that have a lot to explore and a bunch of extra side challenges you can do to spice up the game.

1. Super Mario Galaxy
Best Mario game of all time, amazing story, gameplay and especially atmosphere.
12 YrsF$#
abatage
Coach
#6
's Avatar
12 YrsF$#
Okay, so here's my list of the GotM games I've played, ranked by preference (1 being best):
Totally based on my own preference/enjoyment - most of these are decent games in their own right.

1 Doom (1993)
2 Beneath a Steel Sky
3 God of War
4 Yakuza Kiwami
5 Doom (2016)
6 The Secret of Monkey Island
7 Doom 3
8 DOOM II: Hell On Earth
9 Bioshock
10 Hitman (2016)
11 Horizon Zero Dawn
12 Journey
13 Night in the Woods
14 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance
15 Unreal Gold
16 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
17 Thimbleweed Park
18 Darksiders
19 Pyre
20 Shadow of the Colossus
21 Little Nightmares
22 Transistor
23 Fallout 4
24 Spiritfarer
25 Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice
26 A Plague Tale: Innocence
27 Donkey Kong Country
28 The Outer Worlds
29 Oxenfree
30 Bioshock 2
31 Bayonetta
32 Kentucky Route Zero
33 Alan Wake
34 Prince of Persia 2008
35 Tales from the Borderlands
36 Untitled Goose Game
37 Minesweeper
38 Stories: The Path of Destinies
39 Blasphemous
40 The Witcher
41 Dragon Age Origins
42 Hyper Light Drifter
43 Tunic
44 Gris
45 A Short Hike
46 Bit. Trip Runner
----Bit. Trip Beat
----Bit. Trip Fate
----Bit. Trip Void
----Bit. Trip Core
47 LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game
48 Wargroove
49 Doki Doki Literature Club
50 Crypt of the NecroDancer
51 Oddworld: Abe’s Oddysee
52 Borderlands
53 Child of Light
54 Ori and the Blind Forest
55 Alien: Isolation
56 Celeste
57 The Messenger
58 Conker’s Bad Fur Day


That's about as close as I can get, or care to get =)
10 Yrs#
knalb
#7
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
It's always good too have a good natter but which games have caused the most discussions. Throughout the years we have had 4635 posts overall for each game with a average of 35 posts per thread and 29 Median.

A few notes on this Spiritfarer has been excluded due to it being early in the month and Discord threads are not counted due to it not being easy to count the thread counts in the discord app. Also if the count is the posts are the same for each thread then the view count will determine the which is a higher ranking

Most discussed threads
User Image
3rd - Hades - 93 posts

User ImageUser ImageUser Image
2nd - Triple Creature Feature #7 - 94 posts

User Image
1st - Final Fantasy VII - 150 posts

Least Discussed Threads
User Image
3rd - Project Zero / Fatal Frame - 7 posts / 3200 views

User Image
2nd - Untitled Goose Game - 7 posts/ 1900 views

User Image
1st - Maldita Castilla - 4 posts

Full List
1 Final Fantasy VII 150
2 Triple Creature Feature #7 94
3 Hades 93
4 Elden Ring 88
5 Super Mario World 87
6 Alan Wake 79
7 Triple Creature Feature #8 69
8 Fallout 66
9 Triple Creature Feature #5 66
10 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time 65
11 Triple Creature Feature #6 65
12 Triple Creature Feature #4 55
13 Triple Creature Feature #3 55
14 Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch 55
15 Oxenfree 54
16 Banjo Kazooie 53
17 Journey 53
18 Earthbound 52
19 Borderlands Series 52
20 A Plague Tale: Innocence 51
21 Observer 50
22 Night in the Woods 48
23 Ori and the Blind Forest 48
24 Pyre 46
25 The Outer Worlds 45
26 The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages 45
27 LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game 42
28 Super Metroid 41
29 Gris 39
30 The Witcher 38
31 Final Fantasy 38
32 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order 37
33 God of War 37
34 The Messenger 37
35 Persona 5 Royal 36
36 Triple Creature Feature #2 35
37 Chrono Trigger 34
38 Deus Ex 32
39 Beyond Good & Evil 32
40 Shadow of the Colossus 32
41 Parasite Eve 31
42 Binary Domain 30
43 Valkyria Chronicles 30
44 Hyper Light Drifter 30
45 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night 29
46 Mega Man (1-6) 29
47 Disco Elysium 29
48 Hollow Knight 28
49 Fallout 4 28
50 Prince of Persia 2008 28
51 999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors 28
52 Stories: The Path of Destinies 28
53 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance 28
54 Wargroove 27
55 Unreal Gold 25
56 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 24
57 Yakuza Kiwami 23
58 A Short Hike 23
59 Metroid Prime 23
60 Horizon Zero Dawn 22
61 Transistor 22
62 Oddworld: Abe’s Oddysee 22
63 OMORI 22
64 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past 22
65 Dragon Age Origins 21
66 The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker 21
67 Bayonetta 20
68 Deadly Premonition 20
69 Okami 20
70 Odin Sphere 20
71 Celeste 19
72 Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice 19
73 Tunic 17
74 Yakuza 0 16
75 Crypt of the NecroDancer 16
76 Triple Creature Feature#1 15
77 Minesweeper 15
78 Bit. Trip Series 15
79 Donkey Kong Country 15
80 Live a Live 15
81 Cthulhu Saves the World 14
82 Lost Odyssey 14
83 Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak 14
84 Omikron: The Nomad Soul 13
85 Child of Light 13
86 Hitman (2016) 13
87 Conker’s Bad Fury Day 13
88 Beneath a Steel Sky 12
89 Bayonetta 2 12
90 Kentucky Route Zero 12
91 MediEvil 11
92 The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap 11
93 Darksiders 11
94 The Secret of Monkey Island 10
95 Thimbleweed Park 10
96 Rayman Legends 9
97 Super Mario Galaxy 9
98 Nier 8
99 Project Zero / Fatal frame 7
100 Untitled Goose Game 7
101 Maldita Castilla 4
10 Yrs#
knalb
#8
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
Sometimes a franchise is big and vast which such potential that GotM has had to have multiple dips into these franchises but which franchises have been the most popular. We have had 14 different franchises with repeat entries for a total of 46 games and 31 separate threads.
Note: If a franchise is Underlined then it means these games where part of a collection/series nomination before we excluded multi game nominations:

Franchises

User ImageUser ImageUser ImageUser Image
User ImageUser ImageUser ImageUser ImageUser Image
4th - Bayonetta / Bioshock / Castlevania / Fallout / Final Fantasy / Metroid / Resident Evil / Super Mario / Yakuza - 2 Games

User ImageUser Image
3rd - Borderlands / Doom - 4 Games

User Image
2nd - Mega Man - 6 Games

User ImageUser Image
1st - Bit. Trip / The Legend of Zelda - 7 Games
6 Yrs#
Son_of_a_Pitch
#9
's Avatar
6 Yrs#
Replying to knalb
I’m always kind of proud my nomination for Final Fantasy VII did so well. Granted it was at the perfect time to succeed right before the remake came out and when lots of people were quarantined from Covid.
5 Yrs#
Illusera
#10
's Avatar
5 Yrs#
I've played 17 16 games that were covered by Game of the Month but I was only officially part of 5. I'll include them anyway; sorry if that's cheating.
[*** Marks the games I participated for]

1 - Okami
I just loved everything about this game. The characters, art style, folklore... when the game went into "overtime" I was actually happy because I wanted to keep going.

2 - Odin Sphere
I've replayed the original version many times even though the PS2 version lagged in some bits. The fairytale aesthetics and feel draws me in every time.

3 - Persona 5
I do love Persona 5 but for some reason Persona 4 just drew me in more. Not sure why.

4 - LOZ: Breath of the Wild***
Haven't finished this yet but I do love it. I have some complaints *coughGYROSCOPEcough* but I have gotten into it and I look forward to playing it again when I put it down.

5 - Resident Evil 4
I'm really glad this was my first Resident Evil game because it moved me to want to play the rest of the main series. This helped me at least start into horror games.

6 - Journey***
A peaceful game for me. I was lucky enough to finish the game with the same person the first time I played so it was overall just a good experience.

7 - LOZ: Majora's Mask***
It's a little special to me because I set out with the expectation that it would be retired. I not only finished it but collected all of the masks. Used a guide, but I didn't hate doing so. The sidequests really do make this game.

8 - Final Fantasy VII***
Don't get me wrong, it's a great game and had some great plot twists. I just don't have the same connection that other fans seem to have. Maybe I had to be there when it first came out.

9 - Beyond Good & Evil
I can't quite remember if I finished this. I remember playing some of it and did like it, but it might be one that I just dropped and never returned to. I've seen my sister replay this several times and do like the characters and the story. I should go back to it someday.

10 - MediEvil
Enjoyed this more than MediEvil 2, but going into this game with the rough controls was, uh, rough.

11 - Celeste
Yes, I used the assist menu. But only when I got close to the last part of the game so hopefully that counts for something. I made it farther than I would have expected without it though, and just that was satisfying.

12 - A Short Hike
A cozy game to be sure, but not one that I feel the need to go back to.

13 - Alien: Isolation
Wish I could have gotten farther in this but I stink at stealth. Great atmosphere, I felt like something was out to get me everytime I breathed.

14 - LOZ: Link to the Past***
I'm glad I played and finished this. So why is it all the way down here? Because I had to have my head stuck in a walkthrough for it. Ah well, still a good game though.

15 - Crypt of the Necrodancer - No wait, that was Cadence of Hyrule. I tried to get into it 3 times and failed 3 times.

15 - Mega Man 3
I only finished 1 Mega Man game from the legacy collection and can't remember which. So you can imagine what my experience was.

16 - Minesweeper
Truly, the only thing I enjoyed about this no matter what version I played in any point in time was KingM's mission log. Carry on, soldier.
3 Yrs#
domido
#11
's Avatar
3 Yrs#
I've played 32 games so far, and I retired 4. I tier ranked them, within the tier there is not set order.

User Image

10 Yrs#
knalb
#12
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
...So with a big list potential I suspect alot of you have had a chance to some all the games won of the GotM only to find that there a total of 535309 of the games backlogged with a Average of 4055 Backlogs and a median of 3041 backlogs. My dissapointment is paramount. These are the least and most backlogged games:

Backlogs

Most Backlogged
User Image
3rd - Darksiders - 14856

User Image
2nd - Bioshock - 20702

User Image
1st - Bioshock 2 - 21259

Least Backlogged

User Image
3rd - Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak - 71

User Image
2nd - Maldita Castilla - 19

User Image
1st - Minesweeper - 15

Full List
1 Bioshock 2 21259
2 Bioshock 20702
3 Darksiders 14856
4 Borderlands 2 13378
5 Hollow Knight 12711
6 The Witcher 11365
7 Fallout 4 10116
8 Doom (2016) 9901
9 Alan Wake 9326
10 Transistor 9249
11 Dead Space 9185
12 Alien: Isolation 8867
13 Borderlands: The Pre sequel 8826
14 Final Fantasy VII 8549
15 Deus Ex 8241
16 Yakuza 0 7544
17 Okami 7501
18 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 7458
19 Bayonetta 7420
20 Outlast 7322
21 Fallout 7319
22 Borderlands 7293
23 Resident Evil 4 7082
24 Hitman (2016) 6956
25 Prey (2017) 6833
26 Little Nightmares 6761
27 Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice 6709
28 Hades 6475
29 Valkyria Chronicles 6410
30 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance 5997
31 Child of Light 5905
32 Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch 5861
33 Celeste 5734
34 Yakuza Kiwami 5659
35 Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order 5632
36 Oddworld: Abe’s Oddysee 5412
37 Resident Evil 5304
38 Soma 5262
39 Chrono Trigger 5209
40 Hyper Light Drifter 5185
41 LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game 5052
42 Crypt of the NecroDancer 5050
43 Disco Elysium 5034
44 Oxenfree 4912
45 Rayman Legends 4673
46 A Plague Tale: Innocence 4606
47 Tales from the Borderlands 4562
48 Elden Ring 4514
49 Dragon Age Origins 4463
50 Beyond Good & Evil 4370
51 The Evil Within 4278
52 Binary Domain 4241
53 Ori and the Blind Forest 4069
54 Blasphemous 3860
55 Gris 3790
56 Persona 5 Royal 3768
57 The Outer Worlds 3677
58 Bit. Trip Runner 3511
59 Kentucky Route Zero 3491
60 Cthulhu Saves the World 3461
61 Deadly Premonition 3374
62 Journey 3311
63 The Secret of Monkey Island 3269
64 Bayonetta 2 3187
65 Horizon Zero Dawn 3174
66 Wargroove 3042
67 DOOM II: Hell On Earth 3039
68 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past 2993
69 Earthbound 2981
70 Bit. Trip Presents Runner 2: Future Legend of Rhythm Alien 2971
71 The Messenger 2903
72 Super Mario Galaxy 2856
73 Observer 2803
74 Doki Doki Literature Club 2750
75 Doom 3 2657
76 Prince of Persia 2008 2632
77 Pyre 2602
78 Night in the Woods 2571
79 Stories: The Path of Destinies 2308
80 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night 2293
81 Super Metroid 2280
82 Spiritfarer 2092
83 The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap 2091
84 Metroid Prime 2019
85 Shadow of the Colossus 1917
86 Unreal Gold 1871
87 The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages 1824
88 The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask 1772
89 Bit. Trip Beat 1713
90 A Short Hike 1711
91 God of War 1700
92 The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time 1665
93 Super Mario World 1648
94 Final Fantasy 1526
95 Banjo Kazooie 1523
96 Omikron: The Nomad Soul 1491
97 The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker 1464
98 Lost Odyssey 1419
99 The Cat Lady 1359
100 OMORI 1349
101 Donkey Kong Country 1344
102 Thimbleweed Park 1336
103 Untitled Goose Game 1327
104 Silent Hill 1257
105 Tunic 1215
106 Nier 1193
107 Doom (1993) 1124
108 Parasite Eve 1059
109 Beneath a Steel Sky 959
110 999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors 888
111 Conker’s Bad Fury Day 776
112 Castlevania 736
113 Project Zero / Fatal frame 642
114 Live a Live 624
115 Odin Sphere 597
116 Mega Man 2 577
117 Corpse Party 567
118 Mega Man 3 497
119 Bit. Trip Core 468
120 Mega Man 465
121 Bit. Trip Void 456
122 Bit. Trip Fate 447
123 Mega Man 4 435
124 Mega Man 6 434
125 Mega Man 5 427
126 MediEvil 351
127 Bit. Trip Flux 330
128 Clock Tower 187
129 Saya No Uta 180
130 Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak 71
131 Maldita Castilla 19
132 Minesweeper 15
6 Yrs$#
ThomasE
#13
's Avatar
6 Yrs$#
I've beaten 16 out of the 100 GOTM games.

999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors
Blasphemous
Celeste
Child of Light
Disco Elysium
Doki Doki Literature Club!
Fallout
Fallout 4
Hades
Hollow Knight
Journey
Ori and the Blind Forest: Definitive Edition
Oxenfree
Pyre
Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
The Messenger

I can't even rank them. I think they are all at least really good. My favourite is Hollow Knight, my least favourite is either Oxenfree or Child of Light (but I really enjoyed all 16 games).
5 Yrs#
Illusera
#14
's Avatar
5 Yrs#
Replying to knalb
Minesweeper was actually backlogged? 😶 By the time of this post, 16 times. Its popularity is catching.
10 Yrs#
knalb
#15
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
Replying to Illusera
haha okay. I calculated all these values last month so unfort it won't be fully true but I doubt rankings will of changed in that time.

Bit of a spoiler but your going to see minesweeper alot in these rankings
4 Yrs$#
Siver
#16
's Avatar
4 Yrs$#
While I haven't participated in very many, I have played a fair few games that were GotMs. I've finished 27. I've played but not finished 15.

I attempted to rank the games I finished but it's just too hard. The first one and the last three I think I'm settled on. Everything else is fuzzy as heck. Everything here is good in some way; the only ones I am more meh on is Final Fantasy I and Oxenfree. Oxenfree was the first GotM thread I participated in though.

Chrono Trigger
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Secret of Monkey Island
Pyre
Gris
Disco Elysium
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Lost Odyssey
Journey
Donkey Kong Country
Earthbound
Metroid Prime
Kentucky Route Zero
Super Metroid
Live A Live
Rayman Legends
Spiritfarer
Untitled Goose Game
Super Mario World
Transistor
Valkyria Chronicles
Shadow of the Colossus
A Short Hike
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
Oxenfree
Final Fantasy


Unfinished and unranked
Cthulhu Saves the World
Okami
Minish Cap (in progress!)
Hollow Knight
Final Fantasy VII
Hades
Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch
Hyper Light Drifter (retired)
Ori and the Blind Forest
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages
The Messenger
Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak (retired)
Super Mario Galaxy
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Crypt of the Necrodancer
10 Yrs#
knalb
#17
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
Seen alot people mention playing the GotM but not participating. I'll say that it does not matter and rank them even if you didn't participate in the GotM. Be good though to mention any game you found and loved due to GotM (i.e. a game you've never thought of playing)
3 Yrs#
domido
#18
's Avatar
3 Yrs#
The games I found and loved through GotM were Hades, 999, The Messenger, Super Metroid, Bayonetta, Disco Elysium and Ni No Kuni. I participated in most of these discussions.
4 Yrs$#
Siver
#19
's Avatar
4 Yrs$#
Oxenfree was the only game I played first because of GotM. Others I participated in were replays for me such as Disco Elysium and DKC or ones I didn't end up replaying for it but still poked into the discussion a little.

I missed so many great ones that I'd played before myself but their month was long before I joined the site: Chrono Trigger! Pyre! Earthbound! Lost Odyssey! I'm surprised Lost Odyssey won honestly. I should go poking back through the threads.

...would 6.5 years be too long to revive a thread? I do have Minish Cap going now after all...
10 Yrs#
knalb
#20
's Avatar
10 Yrs#
Replying to Siver
Nah I revive them all the time. Go ahead
9 Yrs$#
tiamat911
Moderator
#21
's Avatar
9 Yrs$#
These are the games of the month that I've beaten. I'm surprised I've got so many. 32 games in total.

Beaten before I joined HLTB (no submission in my profile):

Parasite Eve
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
Mega Man 2 & 3
The Legend of Zelda: Minich Cap

Beaten outside of the GotM events:

Bayonetta
The Secret of Monkey Island
God of War (2005)
The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker
Child of Light
Shadow of the Colossus
Final Fantasy
Darksiders
Celeste
Journey
Super Metroid
A Short Hike
The Messenger
Super Mario Galaxy
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Donkey Kong Country
Metroid Prime
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Beaten for the GotM events:

Stories: The Path of Destinies
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
LEGO The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game
Banjo-Kazooie
Oxenfree
Gris
Super Mario World
Alan Wake
Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice
3 Yrs#
BoiGh0sT
#22
's Avatar
3 Yrs#
I personally haven't participated in the GotMs until recently. I just started checking the forums last December, so I have missed out on a lot of discussions. In terms of ranking the games I have finished, it is quite hard to do so since they're all in different genres. I had fun playing all of the games that I have completed, and I would like to give my thoughts on them, but that might just spam the whole GotM thread and cover up the recent ones, which I don't want to happen.

Completed:
Bayonetta
Borderlands series
Rayman Legends
The Evil Within
God of War
Minesweeper
999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors (An amazing visual novel, and my favorite among the Zero Escape trilogy)
Outlast
Final Fantasy
Yakuza 0 (The best Yakuza game for me)
Yakuza Kiwami
Celeste (A great platformer. I love the art style.)
Oxenfree
Super Mario World
Journey
Elden Ring (The game I enjoyed the most, but also got frustrated)
Doom (2016)
Donkey Kong Country
Persona 5 Royal (Even though the game is long, it is quite enjoyable until the end)

Half of my backlog also consists of other GotM titles that I own but am still finding time to complete. I would definitely like to participate more in the future, but for now I'll put the games that interest me on my wishlist. I am still working on my Metroid Prime game after all 😂.

6 Yrs#
Son_of_a_Pitch
#23
's Avatar
6 Yrs#
Completed: (Bolded if I participated) (Underlined if I nominated)
Fallout 4
Mega Man
Mega Man 2
Earthbound
The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap
Tales from the Borderlands
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
Chrono Trigger
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Shadow of the Colossus
Banjo-Kazooie
Bioshock
Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
Final Fantasy VII
Doki Doki Literature Club
Super Mario World
Journey
Super Metroid
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages
Bioshock 2
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
Castlevania
Donkey Kong Country
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Backlog:
Deus Ex
Oddworld: Abe's Odyssey
Mega Man 3 - 6
Resident Evil: HD Remaster
Beyond Good & Evil
Doom
Hollow Knight
Final Fantasy
Fallout
Hitman (2016)
Super Mario Galaxy
Metroid Prime

Retired:
Horizon Zero Dawn
Lego The Lord of the Rings: The Video Game
Little Nightmares

So overall I've completed 25 games we've done, which 9 of those I was able to participate in that month. I believe I've only ever had 2 games I've nominated win. 3 of the games I retired, although that was either before or after we did them. There are 12 games I have backlogged and plan to play someday. I also didn't realize how many of the games I've gotten for free until I was going through the list now, although many of them I haven't backlogged since I don't know if I want to play them.
9 Yrs#
erictbar
#24
's Avatar
9 Yrs#
Completed during GotM
Persona 5 Royal
OMORI
Untitled Goose Game
Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak
Disco Elysium

Disco Elysium is one I didn't vote for because I had no idea what it was about but was glad to play it.
Untitled Goose Game is the one I had on my backlog for awhile and GotM got me to complete it

Completed, but not for GotM:
Tales from the Borderlands
Horizon Zero Dawn
The Secret of Monkey Island
Beneath a Steel Sky (1994)
Donkey Kong Country
A Short Hike
Doki Doki Literature Club!
GRIS
Oxenfree
Celeste

Retired During GotM
Conker's Bad Fur Day
Crypt of the NecroDancer
Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance
Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice
Tunic
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past

Also an outstanding 19 GotM games retired not during GotM.
Each list in no particular order.
4 Yrs#
dragonh89
#25
's Avatar
4 Yrs#
Apparently, I've beaten 38 GotM games (thanks Mega Man), currently playing 1 (Spiritfarer), retired 4 of them, have 4 in my backlog, and tried at some point in my life 8 more of them (without really wanting to add them to my backlog nor retiring them). So in total I've been in contact with 55 of them! Not too bad, I'd say

So, let's get to the ranking of the ones I've beaten, I guess. I ranked them in Top 5, High, Mid, and Low. However, I want to say that this rating is not from my enjoyment on these games in a vacuum, but my enjoyment of them within the GotMs. I'd say I enjoyed all of the ones I've beaten (and that's why I didn't retire them at the time). All sections are also ordered, with maybe some wiggle room within games that are right next to each other

TOP 5
Persona 5 Royal
Yakuza 0
Resident Evil 4
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
Hades

HIGH
Pyre
Celeste
Mega Man 1-6 (Won't rank them on their own. Have too many opinions on each of these and it'd take me too long. Their individual order would be 4-3-5-2-1-6)
Hollow Knight
999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors
The Messenger
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Yakuza Kiwami

MID
Donkey Kong Country
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time
Wargroove
OMORI
A Short Hike
Super Mario Galaxy
Crypt of the NecroDancer
Doom (2016)
Little Nightmares
Super Mario World
DOOM II: Hell On Earth
Ori and the Blind Forest
Bit. Trip Runner
Hyper Light Drifter
Shadow of the Colossus

LOW
Night in the Woods
Bioshock
Oxenfree
Hamtaro: Ham-Ham Heartbreak
The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages

Somewhat of a nice bell curve there since I'm ranking them within the GotM games. I kind of like how I have a tloz game in every single one of these categories, but apart from that I don't think there is much more I can say in general about a list this big. Interesting to go through for myself, that's for sure

And just for completions sake, here are the other games I've interacted with, but have not beaten (please don't hate me for some of these)

CURRENTLY PLAYING - Spiritfarer
RETIRED - Horizon Zero Dawn, Disco Elysium, Earthbound, Conker’s Bad Fury Day
BACKLOGGED - Child of Light, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, Gris, Untitled Goose Game
TRIED BEFORE - The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask, Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy, Banjo Kazooie, God of War, Super Metroid, Castlevania, Minesweeper