80%PC

Chapters feel repetitive, and a couple chapters are a slog.

75%PlayStation 4

Multiplayer is abandoned by developers.

Story missions are too linear, limited freedom and much of cut content.

100%PC

Absolutely perfect. with much spoiled for me I still loved the game. towards the end i started playing the game the way intended and taking my absolute time with it. it was a beautiful game. each and every part of it. arthur will forever be one of my favorite characters of all time.

90%PC

Overall => 92 / 100

---------------------------
Gameplay (25 / 30 points)

How fun is it to play? - Incredibly fun. Can play either hero or villain (bandit/outlaw)
Is it easy to control? - For the most part, but there has been occasions controls didn't respond after leaving a menu mid horse chase, stuff like that. Or where trying to navigate with a horse at high speeds has caused issues.
Does it feel smooth and responsive? - For the most part, but there has been some stutter early on in the game for me.

---------------------------
Graphics and Sound (18 / 20 points)

How does the game look? Incredible! Even with optimised settings, not fully maxed out.
How's the music and sound effects? I find it immersive, and gun shots sound great. Some little effects here and there take away from this (lasso missing and hitting ground for example)

---------------------------
Story and Characters (20 / 20 points)

Is the story interesting? Yes!
Do you like the characters? Yes!

---------------------------
Replay Value (15 / 15 points)

Do you want to play it again? - This is already my 2nd playthrough.
Is there extra content or different ways to play? - Plenty of side quests, collectibles, as well as the online mode.

---------------------------
Innovation (10 / 10 points)

Does it bring anything new to the table? Bounties, different mini games, dead-eye system
Is it different from other games you've played? - Based on the Red Dead series (not just RDR2), yes.

---------------------------
Polish (4 / 5 points)

Are there bugs or glitches? - Some bugs, none game breaking.

100%PC

Uma experiência, melhor jogo em todos os aspectos possíveis. Arco do Arthur Morgan é lindo e sensível

80%PC

An excellent cowboy game from Rockstar Games, with a long and deep plot, a large number of diverse mechanics and memorable characters

100%Xbox One

Game is fantastic, probably my objective best game of all time. Great story, soundtrack, gameplay, graphics, characters, side content of any game ever. Play it!

100%PC

História
O que dizer sobre a história desse game?
Eu diria que Red Dead Redemption 2 é um exemplo perfeito que os jogos podem superar filmes em questão de enredo.
Somos apresentado a um personagem que a princípio você não dá nada, mas que com o passar do jogo, você percebe o quão carismático ele é, chegando ao ponto de você se apegar muito a ele. Não só o protagonista é muito bem desenvolvido, mas todos os personagens secundários tem suas histórias e relações com o Arthur.
É realmente incrível como a Rockstar conseguiu criar um vínculo tão grande entre o jogador e o bando, fazendo você passar por diversas emoções em relação a todo o contexto em que eles estão inseridos.
Como se não bastasse, cada cidade e local do mapa parece querer te apresentar um história sobre aquele lugar através dos detalhes, NPC's e missões secundárias. O mundo aqui parece vivo como um todo, tendo diversos encontros aleatórios diferentes, que podem consumir algumas horas de gameplay.
O clímax do jogo é digno de um filme de Holywood (como outras diversas cenas), e te traz uma montanha-russa de emoções.

Gameplay
Jogando Red Dead Redemption 2, fico imaginando como uma game vai conseguir supera-lo em questão de gameplay (6 anos se passaram, e até hoje nenhum game superou).
O nível de detalhe que o jogo apresenta em relação as mecânicas é impressionante, trazendo uma imersão nunca antes vista. Se eu fosse citar cada coisa, essa análise ficaria gigante de tanto conteúdo.
Você tem que cuidar não só do ser personagem, mas de seu cavalo, das armas que você carrega e até mesmo das pessoas que fazem parte do seu bando e que você encontra aleatoriamente. A impressão que dá, é que nada aqui é repetitivo e cada situação que você passa é única, trazendo consequências para o universo em que você se encontra.
As missões secundárias são inúmeras, e sempre apresentam uma história única para ser contada, sendo elas quase nunca repetitivas.

Gráficos/Arte
Outro ponto em que até hoje, nenhuma empresa conseguiu superar o jogo.
A densidade de detalhe do universo de Red Dead Redemption é indescritível.
Não só os gráficos (tecnicamente falando) é algo totalmente fora da curva, mas a direção de arte e a ambientação é algo impressionante que eu nunca vi em qualquer outro jogo até hoje. Tudo tem uma pegada mais realista aqui, sendo a física do jogo muito coerente.
A trilha sonora é maravilhosa, se encaixando perfeitamente em cada momento do jogo.
"Se a gente vive em uma simulação, esse game seria um exemplo perfeito desse contexto".

Conclusão
Red Dead Redemption 2 entra facilmente na lista dos melhores jogos que já joguei na vida. É um jogo que tem um nível de detalhe e realismo tão grande, que quando você parte para outros jogos até se decepciona. Temos aqui uma história digna de uma Oscar, trazendo um personagem com um desenvolvimento magnífico que vai te trazer diversas emoções durante sua trajetória. É um jogo perfeito!!!

Nota: 10/10

Pontos que poderiam melhorar:
- Nenhum! O jogo é perfeito em seu propósito 👏

100%PC

This game is a masterpiece.

80%Xbox One

I still like the first one better

100%PC

Best game of all time in my opinion. It is so beautiful and breathtaking, visuals are insanely good 6 years later. The weapon mechanics are really fun, interesting and overall fit really well with the style of the game. I love the horse bonding mechanic and honor system, truly adds more depth and consequences to your actions. Such a well-written story, funny at times, sad at times, bitter-sweet, etc. This game is an emotional rollercoaster that is not boring. If you have a PC, get this and mod it to make it 10x more fun. My favorite game of all time.

100%PC

The best game I've ever played

100%PlayStation 4

8/13/24
8/27/24

100%PlayStation 4

2018 GOTY

100%PC

Probably the game that comes closest to perfection. I will admit, this game definitely isn't for everyone. While unbelievably immersive, most of the game just plays in a slow, realistic manner, which will undoubtedly get some players bored. However, for those that don't mind the slower paced gameplay, this is absolutely a must play. I've never witnessed a whole cast being as well directed as this. The gameplay is so well directed well, it fits the game perfectly.

100%Xbox Series X/S

I gave you all I had.

100%PlayStation 4

The best.

100%PlayStation 4

We don’t even need to talk much about it. It’s the best western game ever, the best rockstar game ever, and the only thing better than the incredible world is the breathtaking narrative. One of the best games ever made.

35%PlayStation 4

Very well-made game, but i was bored out of my mind.
Why did i finish it? bc i'm dumb lol
Cool house construction music video

85%Xbox One

Great, but prefer soulslikes over the immersive experience. Story is great though.

90%PlayStation 4

Masterpiece

90%PC

A true role-playing experience

Good
- feels like you're an outlaw cowboy
- great narration
- good story
- beautiful scenery
- interesting characters
- fun missions

Bad
- too much horse riding
- not enough fast travel points

100%PC

Perfect Game

90%PlayStation 4

Terminei o jogo com 204h, fiz algumas side quests, finalizei 100% de um desafio, e obtive 48% de troféus na PSN, fechando assim o jogo, não fiz nenhuma online, detesto online.

100%PlayStation 4

Really good and detailed game, gets a bit boring at some point... But thats when you have something like 90h in it

I tried... And in the end I did

100%PlayStation 4

One of the best story games I ever played. Game Is amazing actors are great. everything is great.

95%PlayStation 4

This is probably my favorite story in a video game I have ever played. Arthur Morgan is such a well written character, which is something that makes this game very special. The map is stunning and the gameplay is fun, per usual in a Rockstar title. In my opinion, this is Rockstar's peak work thus far. GTA 6 is around the corner though....

95%PC

Best story driven game I've played to date. Certain things bothered/annoyed me throughout (see: movement in some instances, horse mechanics, stealth is... yeah). A slow burn at the start, once things pick up, they REALLY pick up.

100%PlayStation 5

I've been an honorable cowpoke, through and through. Loved my horse like kin, and my friends just the same. Helped with the chores as a true farmhand, did what needed doin', and lived my life to the fullest. Dressed myself in legendary pelts, a sight to behold. Mastered poker and blackjack like a true gambler. Gave folks what they wanted. I've faced the harshest storms and rode through the darkest nights. Fought for what's right and stood my ground. Seen the best and worst of humanity. I'll never cook and brew like Pearson, never be as brave as Sadie—she’s one sharp gal, cool as a summer breeze. But I've done my best. What else could a man ask for?

95%PlayStation 4

PEAK

100%PC

The best of the best, stories are great than ever games industry does in a way. Arthur Morgan are so memorable and intack to our minds forever, theres should be sequel for this, it should.

90%PlayStation 4

I played this for over a year and it almost ruined my life. Wonderful game.

100%PC

Without a question, one of the best games ever! Great story, great characters and acting, great gameplay and one of the (if not THE) best open worlds there is.

100%PC

No hay palabras para describir este juego, y tampoco quedan muchas que no se hayan dicho ya. Juego imperdible. Arthur Morgan es el G.O.A.T.

80%PC

Red dead redemption 2 8/10:
-Main Story is great
-Combat is great
-Graphics are great
-The only downside is the Epilogue, which deducted 2 points because ain't nobody wanna play a farm boy in a cowboy game. Literally the most boring shit I have seen
-Once you enter Epilogue you also lose a few items that you had on arthur such as masks that you could find in tombs and other special items

90%PC

Um jogo muito bom, pareceu meio lento no inicio, mas valeu apena a espera.

90%Xbox One

Man.

100%PC

the best game of all time.

80%PC

Rich story, care about the characters, immersive and fresh gameplay, makes me want to play the original game.

Would give it a 9 however due to the technical issues that comes with the PC and spending a couple of hours trying to find the right graphics settings to play on as well as other bugs, giving it an 8 instead.

100%PlayStation 4

Story + Gameplay = one of the best games I've ever played

100%Xbox One

Incredible game. Very fun

100%PC

One of the best game oat

100%PlayStation 5

THIS IS SO AMAZING

100%PC

I am impressed how boring and good this game can be at the same time

100%PlayStation 4

my personal best form the story to the world. this game is 100% amzing all the way

100%PC

I guess... I'm afraid

100%Xbox Series X/S

Simply put, the best story in gaming. Better than most TV shows and movies as well. Even having already known Arthur's fate before playing, all the twists and turns kept on surprising me. I have grown accustomed to disliking Rockstar's styles of missions, but that did not at all deter me from enjoying every second of this game. Mashing the "A" button can get annoying, but it is so worth it. Aside from that, I quite enjoy the gunplay this game brings. The number of bullets and the placement of your shots is very realistic in terms of what it takes to take out enemies. The ending (of the epilogue) is a fantastic way to end things. I intend on replaying this game, or at the very least cleaning up the work I did not do with Arthur, with John.

F*** Micah.

100%PlayStation 4

pek bir şey dememe gerek yok sanki. 11/10

100%PlayStation 5

+ Incredible game overall
+ Realistic
+ Storyline
+ Combat
+ Random encounters
+ Setting
+ Map
+ One of the best games ever made imo

- The beginning is a bit dragged out